October 14, 2012
Your Hypocrisy is Showing

“When they are told that the United States government had no part in the production of the video and deplores its content, educated Libyans and Egyptians reply (reporters tell us), “Well, if they think it’s bad and against their values, why didn’t they stop it or punish those who produced it?” The standard response is that we Americans don’t suppress or penalize ideas we regard as wrong and even dangerous; in accordance with the First Amendment, we tolerate them and allow them to present themselves for possible purchase in the marketplace of ideas.

But that means that protecting the marketplace by refusing to set limits on what can enter it is the highest value we affirm, and we affirm it no matter what truths might be vilified and what falsehoods might get themselves accepted. We have decided that the potential unhappy consequences of a strong free speech regime must be tolerated because the principle is more important than preventing any harm it might permit.”

Tell me again how the First Amendment doesn’t apply to that creepy perv from Reddit. Tell me again how you’re all Champions of Justice for attempting to destroy that asshole’s life.

(Source: The New York Times)

  1. moneymud reblogged this from nineprotons
  2. parkebench reblogged this from totalmachismo and added:
    Here’s the thing, freedom of speech is not freedom from criticism nor freedom from consequences, nor is it the...
  3. totalmachismo reblogged this from sahnin and added:
    I’m not saying he shouldn’t suffer any consequences. There’s a line between saying what someone did is wrong and they’ll...
  4. highenergyjewtrino reblogged this from sahnin and added:
    Oh I absolutely agree with that. And really, the First Amendment has nothing at all to do with interpersonal issues....
  5. sahnin reblogged this from totalmachismo and added:
    These are two separate situations. It’s a bit like comparing apples and oranges, to be honest. I agree with you that the...
  6. nineprotons reblogged this from sahnin and added:
    Yep. Looks like I need to repost that Glue comic I posted a while back because some people still want to whine about the...